The great Favre debate!

[Vanraw]

I understand that the rule may have been correct in the Detroit game and even though I am not a Detroit fan but one just can't help but feel that Detroit got robbed.

If that isn't a catch and touchdown then obviously something is wrong with the NFL's opinion of what a catch is.


Vllad

I'm a Bear fan, and I have to agree (Note that the Bears should never have let them roll down the field.) From my football perspective I think Detriot got robbed. BUT they got robbed because of the new stupid shit rule. My understanding is every training camp was visited and brought up to speed on the new rule. Given that, all Johnson had to do was tuck the ball and roll. Instead he tried to bounce up on his feet as fast as possible to start the celebration.

So, I blame the rule, not the refs.