04-15-2012, 10:48 AM
I would agree with you Xyphos because David Tenant can be excellent but is also far more dramatic and broody than Matt Smith. Frankly after his 3d season I was getting tired of it. Whereas Matt Smith focuses on the age and experience of the Doctor enjoying the crazy and seeing the universe as a challenge/lethal amusement park is more compelling to me. Bottom line, he's adventure and humor where David Tenant was more superhero and melodrama. I think that's why most American audiences prefer him.
wibbly wobbly timey wimey